Tag Archives: horizontalism

Thoughts on Horizontalism, ed. Marina Sitrin

Some years ago, I read the collection Horizontalism: Voices of Popular Power in Argentina by Marina Sitrin. Sitrin collected firsthand accounts of people active in the social movements in Argentina that came after sudden economic devastation in 2001. Sitrin writes:

“The precipitating incident was the government’s freezing of peoples’ bank accounts, and converting their money, once pegged to the U.S. dollar, into a financial asset that would be held by banks and used to secure payment to foreign investors, but that could not be accessed by the depositors. . . . This was the spark dropped on a long smoldering fire. The government of Argentina had taken out huge loans with the IMF in the 1990s, and in the late 90s began to pay these loans back through privatization and severe austerity measures. Thousands of people were laid off, wages and pensions were cut, and social services degraded. . . [B]y 2001 industrial production had fallen by over 25 percent. The official poverty level grew to 44 percent, with the unofficial level substantially higher.” (pp 8-9)

Let’s go back a minute to the word “austerity.” Here is a short definition from an article published in 2022 on the Oxfam International web site: “85% of the world’s population will live in the grip of stringent austerity measures by next year.”

“Austerity measures include scaling down social protection programs for women, children, the elderly and other vulnerable people, leaving only a small safety net for a fraction of the poorest.  They also include cutting or capping the wages and number of teachers and healthcare workers, eliminating subsidies, privatizing or commercializing public services such as energy, water and public transportation, and reducing pensions and workers’ rights.”

 In the past, “austerity” is something that mostly happened to other countries, so those of us in the United States might not have heard of it. (It has been happening here slowly, for quite some time, but that’s a topic for another post.) Well, we’d better learn fast, because it’s going full throttle. In other words, we can defeat “America First” if we realize that we are not the only country in the universe. (For that matter, we’re not even “America.” That’s a continent. It has other countries in it.)

From the global South, those of us in the global North can learn both what might happen and how people might respond.

I’ll try to write more later, but for now I’ll just say, “Go read the book.”

Previous posts about this book:

Gift economies large and small

Gift economies have been with us throughout history. The book Women and the Gift Economy, ed. Genevieve Vaughan, has examples from South Africa, Big Mountain Black Mesa in Arizona, the Carribean, El Salvador,  and elsewhere.

On a smaller scale, and here in the U.S., gift economy projects are all around us. Here are just a few:

  • Little free libraries
  • Open source software
  • Creative Commons
  • Wikipedia
  • Kickstarter
  • Freecycle

There’s also a facebook phenomenon of “Buy Nothing Groups,” local groups where members give away items for free or ask for items. Its organizers had been inspired by the gift economies practiced in villages in Nepal.

And there are “free shops” or “give-away shops” and “The Really, Really Free Market,” which people organize in parks to give away goods.

 #

Here’s my question: is this phenomenon going to change society? Do these new gift economies offer an alternative to capitalism? Or are they a complement to capitalism, the same way shadow work is a complement to wage work?

I’m not saying this to be a downer. I really do hope people will find viable alternatives to capitalism, because capitalism is not working. I am saying it because we need to look critically at the solutions we hope will work, rather than glorifying them just because they are “alternative.” Maybe some gift economies do a better job of resisting exploitation than others. And maybe there are safeguards that can be put in place.

#

I don’t think the answers to my questions will be found in the U.S. and Europe, the so-called “first world.” I think the so-called “third world” is far ahead of us in social innovation. So let’s take a quick visit to Argentina, based on what I learned in the book Horizontalism, ed. Marina Sitrin (2006).

In 2001, Argentina suffered an economic meltdown, caused by the policies of the IMF. Banks froze their accounts and used depositors’ money to pay off foreign debt. Corporations fled. Factories shut down. In other words, capitalism broke itself. How could people survive? A movement was born, called horizontalidad. Or a collection of movements, including occupations of factories and workplaces, unemployed worker movements, new barter systems, direct democracy, neighborhood assemblies, and much more.

When Sitrin edited the book, many of these new movements were being co-opted or were changing in other ways. What has happened since then?

I don’t know the whole story. But fast forward in time to 2010, and a new phenomenon sprung up in Argentina: the gratiferia, meaning the market where everything is free. It has since spread to many other countries.

The grateferia in Argentina is maybe different than, for example, the Buy Nothing Facebook group that I participate in, because it’s maybe informed by a different kind of social consciousness, called politica afectiva (a politics of social relationships). Or just because the people of Argentina know, the way people in the United States do not, what happens when money suddenly disappears, and again, what happens when it comes back.

That’s all for now.

-Kristin

 

Related Links

Women and the Gift Economy, ed. Genevieve Vaughan

Really, really free market

Beginnings of the Buy Nothing Facebook groups

Horizontalism, ed. Marina Sitrin

Gratiferias

Other gift economies

horizontalism